Publication ethics
SCIENTIFIC HUB
Publication Ethics & Publication Malpractice Statement
A Unified Ethical Framework for All Scientific Hub Journals
Our Commitment to Publication Ethics
Scientific Hub is committed to maintaining high standards of integrity, transparency, accountability, and ethical conduct in scholarly publishing. We recognize our responsibility to protect the integrity of the scholarly record and promote responsible research practices.
This Publication Ethics and Publication Malpractice Statement establishes the ethical principles, responsibilities, and procedures applicable to all journals published, managed, or operated under Scientific Hub.
This policy is informed by internationally recognized guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE), International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), World Association of Medical Editors (WAME), and Council of Science Editors (CSE).
Applicability: All journals operating under Scientific Hub, regardless of academic discipline or publication model.
Policy Contents
- Introduction and Scope
- Responsibilities of the Publisher
- Responsibilities of Editors
- Responsibilities of Authors
- Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers
- Peer Review Ethics and Integrity
- Research Involving Humans and Animals
- Research Misconduct and Plagiarism
- Artificial Intelligence Policy
- Conflicts of Interest
- Corrections and Retractions
- Complaints and Appeals
- Copyright and Licensing
- Publication Fees
- Advertising and Sponsorship
- Data Protection
- Archiving and Preservation
- Ethical Investigations
- Whistleblower Protection
- Implementation Across Journals
- Policy Review
- Contact Information
- International References
1. Introduction and Scope
Scientific Hub is dedicated to responsible scholarly communication and the dissemination of reliable, original, and scientifically sound research.
This policy applies to authors, editors, reviewers, editorial board members, and publishing personnel associated with all Scientific Hub journals.
Individual journals may establish additional discipline-specific ethical requirements consistent with this central policy.
2. Responsibilities of the Publisher
Scientific Hub supports editorial independence and ethical publishing practices. The publisher shall:
- Protect the independence of editors and editorial boards.
- Ensure editorial decisions are based on scholarly merit and ethical standards.
- Maintain transparent publication policies and procedures.
- Support investigations into publication misconduct.
- Facilitate corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern.
- Protect confidential manuscript and reviewer information.
- Prevent commercial or financial interests from improperly influencing editorial decisions.
- Promote fairness, inclusivity, and nondiscrimination.
- Provide appropriate complaints and appeals procedures.
- Support long-term preservation of published scholarly content.
3. Responsibilities of Editors and Editorial Boards
3.1 Editorial Independence
Editors must evaluate manuscripts according to originality, scientific validity, methodological quality, relevance, and ethical compliance. Decisions must not be influenced by irrelevant personal characteristics or institutional affiliations.
3.2 Confidentiality
Editors must protect manuscript confidentiality and must not disclose unpublished information to unauthorized individuals or use such material for personal advantage.
3.3 Conflicts of Interest
Editors must disclose relevant conflicts of interest and recuse themselves from decisions where their impartiality could reasonably be questioned.
3.4 Editorial Decisions
Acceptance and rejection decisions must be made by authorized editors, informed by peer review, scientific merit, journal scope, and applicable ethical requirements.
3.5 Ethical Concerns
Editors must evaluate credible allegations of plagiarism, fabrication, falsification, duplicate publication, inappropriate authorship, and peer-review manipulation.
4. Responsibilities of Authors
4.1 Originality and Plagiarism
Authors must submit original work, properly acknowledge sources, and obtain permissions where required. Plagiarism and misleading presentation of another person's work are prohibited.
Similarity-detection software may be used. Similarity percentages alone do not establish plagiarism; editorial assessment must consider context and the nature of the overlap.
4.2 Multiple and Duplicate Submissions
Authors must not submit substantially identical manuscripts to multiple journals simultaneously. Relevant prior dissemination, including preprints and conference proceedings, must be disclosed in accordance with journal policies.
4.3 Research Accuracy
Fabrication, falsification, selective manipulation, or deliberate misrepresentation of research data, images, methods, or results is prohibited.
4.4 Authorship
Authorship must accurately reflect substantial scholarly contributions. All authors must approve the submitted manuscript and accept appropriate accountability. Guest, gift, honorary, and ghost authorship are unacceptable.
4.5 Conflicts of Interest
Authors must disclose relevant financial and nonfinancial relationships that could influence, or appear to influence, their research.
4.6 Funding
Authors must identify relevant funding sources and disclose the role of funders in the research and publication process.
4.7 Research Data
Authors should preserve accurate research records and make supporting data available where appropriate, subject to privacy, confidentiality, legal, and ethical restrictions.
4.8 Published Errors
Authors who identify significant errors in published work must promptly inform the journal and cooperate with appropriate corrective measures.
5. Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers
- Confidentiality: Manuscripts and associated information must remain confidential.
- Objectivity: Reviews must be impartial, constructive, respectful, and evidence-based.
- Competence: Reviewers should accept assignments only within their expertise.
- Timeliness: Reviews should be completed within agreed deadlines.
- Conflicts of Interest: Relevant conflicts must be disclosed to the editor.
- Ethical Reporting: Suspected plagiarism, data irregularities, or other misconduct should be reported confidentially to the editor.
- AI Confidentiality: Confidential manuscripts must not be uploaded to external AI services without appropriate authorization.
6. Peer Review Ethics and Integrity
Scientific Hub supports independent, fair, rigorous, and transparent peer review. Individual journals must disclose their peer-review models and editorial procedures.
The following practices are prohibited:
- Fabricated reviewer identities or reports.
- Manipulation of peer-review outcomes.
- Coercive or inappropriate citation requests.
- Unauthorized disclosure of manuscripts.
- Improper interference with editorial decisions.
Publication charges must not determine whether a manuscript is accepted or rejected.
7. Research Involving Humans and Animals
7.1 Human Research
Research involving human participants, identifiable human data, or biological materials must comply with applicable laws and ethical requirements, including the Declaration of Helsinki where relevant.
Authors must disclose research ethics committee or institutional review board approval where required, or provide an appropriate explanation when approval was not necessary.
7.2 Informed Consent
Appropriate informed consent must be obtained where required. Identifiable personal information must not be published without appropriate consent or another valid legal and ethical basis.
7.3 Animal Research
Animal research must comply with relevant animal welfare standards, institutional requirements, and applicable regulations. Authors must disclose required ethical approvals.
7.4 Privacy
Researchers must protect participant privacy, confidentiality, and personal data throughout the research and publication process.
8. Research Misconduct and Plagiarism
Scientific Hub is committed to addressing research misconduct through fair, evidence-based procedures.
Potential misconduct includes:
- Plagiarism and inappropriate content reuse.
- Fabrication or falsification of research data.
- Misleading image manipulation.
- Duplicate or redundant publication.
- Inappropriate authorship practices.
- Citation and peer-review manipulation.
- Misrepresentation of ethical approvals or informed consent.
- Deliberate misrepresentation of methods or findings.
Scientific Hub distinguishes genuine scientific errors from deliberate or reckless misconduct.
9. Artificial Intelligence and AI-Assisted Technologies
9.1 Author Responsibilities
Authors may use AI-assisted tools where permitted by journal policy, but must disclose substantive use when required. Human authors remain responsible for all submitted content.
9.2 AI Authorship
AI systems must not be listed as authors because they cannot assume scholarly accountability or responsibility.
9.3 Verification
Authors must verify AI-assisted outputs, including citations, data, images, and scientific statements. Fabricated references or misleading synthetic research content are prohibited.
9.4 Editors and Reviewers
Editors and reviewers must protect confidential manuscripts when using AI-assisted tools. AI must not replace accountable human editorial judgment.
10. Conflicts of Interest and Disclosure
Authors, reviewers, editors, and relevant publishing personnel must disclose financial, professional, institutional, or personal relationships that may influence scholarly work or editorial judgment.
Disclosed conflicts must be assessed and appropriately managed. A conflict does not automatically prevent publication, but it must not compromise research or editorial integrity.
11. Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern
11.1 Corrections
Corrections may be published when errors affect a publication's accuracy or interpretation without invalidating its overall findings.
11.2 Retractions
Retractions may be issued when findings are unreliable or serious ethical violations justify withdrawal from the scholarly record. Retraction notices should clearly explain the reasons and identify the affected article.
11.3 Expressions of Concern
An expression of concern may be issued when serious questions remain unresolved or an investigation is ongoing.
11.4 Fair Investigation
Relevant parties should receive a reasonable opportunity to respond before corrective action is finalized. Retracted articles should ordinarily remain accessible and clearly marked, except where compelling legal or privacy reasons require otherwise.
12. Complaints and Appeals
Scientific Hub supports fair procedures for handling complaints and appeals relating to editorial decisions, peer review, and publication ethics.
Authors may appeal decisions where they identify a significant factual error, procedural irregularity, or relevant conflict of interest.
Appeals must include a clear explanation and supporting evidence. Complaints should initially be directed to the relevant journal's editorial office and may be escalated to the publisher where appropriate.
An appeal does not guarantee reversal of an editorial decision.
13. Copyright, Licensing, and Intellectual Property
Scientific Hub respects intellectual property rights and supports transparent copyright and licensing arrangements.
Each journal must disclose its copyright ownership rules, publication licenses, reuse permissions, and applicable author rights.
Authors must obtain necessary permissions for third-party copyrighted content. Open-access articles must clearly identify their applicable licenses, including Creative Commons licenses where used.
14. Publication Fees and Editorial Independence
Scientific Hub supports transparency regarding article processing charges, submission fees, and other publication-related costs.
Each journal must clearly disclose applicable charges and any waiver or discount arrangements.
Payment of publication charges must not guarantee acceptance or improperly influence editorial decisions. Authors must be informed of applicable charges before becoming financially committed.
15. Advertising, Sponsorship, and Commercial Influence
Advertising, sponsorship, and commercial relationships must not compromise editorial independence.
Sponsored or promotional content must be clearly distinguished from independently reviewed scholarly material. Commercial arrangements must not result in preferential editorial treatment.
16. Data Protection and Confidentiality
Scientific Hub recognizes the importance of protecting personal information and confidential editorial records.
Personal data must be processed in accordance with applicable data-protection laws and published privacy policies.
Access to confidential manuscript and editorial information must be restricted to authorized personnel. Appropriate organizational and technical safeguards should be maintained.
17. Archiving and Preservation
Scientific Hub recognizes the importance of long-term access to scholarly research.
The publisher and its journals should maintain appropriate digital preservation and archiving arrangements. Each journal should disclose its actual preservation services, repository arrangements, or other applicable archiving mechanisms.
18. Ethical Oversight and Investigations
Credible allegations of publication misconduct should be evaluated fairly, confidentially where appropriate, and without unnecessary delay.
- Initial assessment of the concern.
- Collection and examination of relevant evidence.
- Communication with affected parties.
- Consultation with independent experts or institutions when necessary.
- Determination of appropriate editorial action.
- Documentation and communication of the outcome.
- Publication of corrective notices where warranted.
19. Allegations of Misconduct and Whistleblower Protection
Scientific Hub encourages individuals to report credible concerns regarding research integrity and publication ethics.
Reports should contain sufficient information to permit reasonable assessment. Allegations will be handled impartially, with appropriate attention to confidentiality, privacy, and procedural fairness.
Retaliation against individuals reporting concerns in good faith is unacceptable. Individuals must also be protected against malicious or knowingly false allegations.
20. Implementation Across Scientific Hub Journals
This statement serves as the central publication ethics framework for all journals published, managed, or operated under Scientific Hub.
Each journal is expected to:
- Provide a visible link to this centralized policy.
- Inform authors, reviewers, and editors of applicable responsibilities.
- Apply ethical principles throughout submission, review, publication, and post-publication processes.
- Publish additional discipline-specific requirements where needed.
- Refer serious or unresolved ethical matters to the appropriate publisher representative.
21. Policy Review and Updates
Scientific Hub will periodically review this policy to reflect developments in scholarly publishing, research integrity, technology, applicable regulations, and internationally recognized ethical standards.
The current approved version should remain available on the official Scientific Hub website.
22. Contact for Publication Ethics Concerns
Scientific Hub — Publication Ethics Office
Questions, complaints, appeals, and allegations of publication misconduct should initially be submitted to the editorial office of the relevant journal.
Publisher-level concerns may be referred to the designated Scientific Hub publication ethics contact.
Official Website: https://scientifichubjournals.com
Publication Ethics Email: ethics@scientifichubjournals.com
Publisher: Scientific Hub
23. International References and Ethical Standards
This policy is informed by internationally recognized publishing ethics resources:
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE): publicationethics.org
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE): ICMJE Recommendations
- World Association of Medical Editors (WAME): wame.org
- Council of Science Editors (CSE): councilscienceeditors.org
- World Medical Association: Declaration of Helsinki and related resources
Reference to these organizations does not imply membership, accreditation, or endorsement of Scientific Hub.
SCIENTIFIC HUB
Committed to Research Integrity and Responsible Scholarly Publishing
Publisher-wide Publication Ethics Policy | All Scientific Hub Journals