Peer Review Policy

SCIENTIFIC HUB

Peer Review Policy

A Unified Peer Review Framework for All Scientific Hub Journals

Our Commitment to Peer Review Excellence

Scientific Hub is committed to maintaining high standards of academic quality, independence, fairness, transparency and research integrity. Peer review provides an essential independent assessment of manuscripts submitted to our journals and supports responsible scholarly communication.

This Peer Review Policy defines principles, responsibilities and procedures applicable across journals published, managed or operated under Scientific Hub.

Applicability: All Scientific Hub journals, regardless of academic discipline, subject to clearly disclosed journal-specific arrangements.

1. Introduction and Scope

Scientific Hub is committed to high standards of scholarly quality, integrity, transparency and editorial independence. Independent peer review is a central safeguard in evaluating manuscripts and strengthening the reliability of published research.

This policy establishes a common peer review framework for all journals published, managed or operated under Scientific Hub. It applies to editors, editorial board members, reviewers, authors and authorized publishing personnel.

Individual journals may publish additional discipline-specific requirements, provided that any differences from this policy are clearly identified.

2. Objectives of Peer Review

The purpose of peer review is to support responsible editorial decisions and improve manuscript quality. Reviewers and editors should assess:

  • Originality, relevance and contribution to the subject area.
  • Scientific and methodological soundness, including data analysis where applicable.
  • Whether results support the interpretations and conclusions.
  • Clarity, organization, citations and transparent reporting.
  • Compliance with ethical, legal and journal-specific requirements.

Peer review does not guarantee that a study is error-free; it provides an independent expert evaluation to inform the editorial decision.

3. Peer Review Model

Scientific Hub journals generally aim to apply a double-anonymous peer review model, in which author and reviewer identities are concealed from one another where practicable. Manuscripts should be anonymized where required by the journal.

Some journals or article categories may use single-anonymous, open or other appropriate review models. Each journal must accurately disclose the model it actually uses; a published journal-specific policy takes precedence when it differs from this general description.

The identities and reports of reviewers are handled in accordance with the applicable model, privacy obligations and confidentiality requirements.

4. Peer Review Process

4.1 Manuscript Submission

Authors submit manuscripts through the journal's designated submission system and must follow its author guidelines, ethical requirements and manuscript preparation instructions.

4.2 Initial Editorial Screening

An editor checks the journal's scope, originality, basic scientific and ethical suitability, completeness of declarations and required files. A manuscript may be returned for correction or declined without external peer review if it is unsuitable.

4.3 Reviewer Selection

Editors invite reviewers based on subject expertise, independence and the absence of relevant conflicts of interest. For substantial research contributions, journals generally aim to obtain at least two independent expert reports, subject to the journal's actual procedures. Additional reviewers may be consulted where necessary.

4.4 Independent Evaluation

Reviewers examine originality, methods, evidence, interpretation, scholarly context, reporting quality and ethical compliance, and submit constructive, evidence-based comments to the editor.

4.5 Editorial Decision

Possible decisions are acceptance, minor revision, major revision or rejection. Reviewers provide recommendations; the Editor-in-Chief or authorized handling editor makes the final decision after considering the reports and journal standards.

4.6 Revision and Reassessment

Authors invited to revise should provide an updated manuscript and a point-by-point response to reviewer and editor comments. Revised manuscripts may be sent for further peer review. An invitation to revise does not guarantee acceptance.

4.7 Final Acceptance and Publication

Accepted manuscripts proceed to the journal's production and publication workflow only after relevant editorial, ethical and technical requirements have been met.

5. Responsibilities of Peer Reviewers

Peer reviewers are expected to:

  • Act impartially: provide respectful, constructive, evidence-based evaluations free of personal bias.
  • Review within their expertise: decline invitations when the subject is outside their competence or the agreed deadline cannot be met.
  • Protect confidentiality: do not disclose, distribute or use unpublished material for personal advantage.
  • Disclose conflicts: inform the editor promptly about any actual, potential or perceived competing interests.
  • Report concerns: confidentially identify possible plagiarism, unreliable data, duplicate publication or other misconduct.
  • Avoid manipulation: do not demand unnecessary citations or make inappropriate requests for self-citation.

Reviewers must not delegate a review or share the manuscript with another person without editorial permission.

6. Responsibilities of Editors and Editorial Boards

Editors must select qualified independent reviewers, protect the confidentiality of submissions, manage conflicts of interest and evaluate reports fairly. Editorial decisions must be based on scholarly merit, journal relevance, scientific validity and applicable ethical requirements.

Editors should provide clear decisions and reasonable explanations, avoid discriminatory treatment, handle misconduct allegations appropriately and recuse themselves whenever a conflict could compromise impartiality.

7. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors must submit original, accurate work; disclose funding and competing interests; obtain applicable ethics approval and consent; and observe the instructions of the receiving journal.

Authors are expected to respond professionally to review comments, explain substantive disagreements with evidence and disclose relevant prior dissemination. Simultaneous submission of substantially the same manuscript to multiple journals is prohibited unless expressly permitted. False reviewer identities or attempts to manipulate peer review are unacceptable.

8. Confidentiality and Data Protection

Submitted manuscripts, peer review reports, editorial correspondence and unpublished supporting material are confidential. Access is limited to individuals involved in legitimate editorial or research-integrity functions, subject to appropriate safeguards.

Editors and reviewers must not use unpublished information for personal, financial or competitive benefit. Necessary disclosures to relevant ethics bodies or institutions should be proportionate and consistent with applicable requirements.

9. Conflicts of Interest

Authors, reviewers, editors and publishing personnel must disclose relationships that might influence, or appear to influence, their professional judgment. Examples include financial interests, recent collaboration, close personal relationships, direct competition and relevant institutional connections.

Editors assess disclosures and may replace a reviewer, reassign a manuscript or adopt other safeguards to preserve the independence of the assessment.

10. Ethical Standards and Research Integrity

Scientific Hub prohibits plagiarism, fabrication or falsification of data, inappropriate image manipulation, duplicate publication, citation manipulation, fabricated review reports and other forms of editorial or research misconduct.

Credible concerns are examined fairly and confidentially where appropriate. Editors may request source data, explanations, ethical approval records or independent expert advice. Appropriate outcomes can include rejection, correction, expression of concern or retraction, depending on the stage of publication and the findings.

11. Peer Review Timelines

Scientific Hub supports timely peer review and clear communication. The time required depends on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, journal workload and the extent of revisions.

Individual journals may publish expected review and decision timelines, but such estimates do not constitute guarantees of an editorial decision, acceptance or publication by a particular date.

12. Editorial Independence

Editorial decisions must remain independent of advertising, sponsorship, institutional pressure and publication charges. Editors evaluate submissions on their scientific and scholarly merits, suitability for the journal and ethical compliance.

Payment of an article processing charge, where applicable, never guarantees acceptance or favorable review.

13. Appeals and Complaints

Authors who believe that a decision involved a significant factual error, procedural irregularity or relevant conflict of interest may submit a reasoned appeal with supporting evidence to the journal's editorial office.

The appeal should be assessed by the Editor-in-Chief or an independent authorized editor; where the Editor-in-Chief is involved, another qualified person should handle the matter. Additional expert advice may be requested. An appeal does not guarantee a change in the outcome.

Complaints about reviewer behavior, fairness, confidentiality or editorial procedures will be considered through the relevant journal and publisher channels.

14. Special Manuscript Categories

Original research articles, reviews, systematic reviews, case reports and similar scholarly contributions are generally subjected to external peer review where appropriate.

Editorials, invited commentaries, letters, book reviews and other non-research contributions may receive editorial assessment or external review according to the journal's published procedures. Publications that have not undergone external peer review should be identified clearly when relevant.

15. Submissions from Editors and Editorial Board Members

Manuscripts authored by an editor, editorial board member or a person with a close relationship to the journal must be independently managed. The submitting individual must not select reviewers, access confidential reviewer identities inappropriately, take part in editorial deliberations or decide the outcome of their own submission.

Editorial board membership does not confer preferential review or guarantee publication.

16. Artificial Intelligence in Peer Review

Editors and reviewers remain personally accountable for the accuracy, confidentiality and integrity of their assessments. Unpublished manuscripts and related confidential information must not be uploaded to public or unapproved AI systems without explicit authorization and appropriate privacy safeguards.

AI-assisted tools must not replace independent expert evaluation or editorial judgment. Any permitted substantive use should be disclosed where required by the relevant journal.

17. Transparency and Continuous Improvement

Scientific Hub encourages regular evaluation of reviewer quality, editorial consistency, conflicts management and review efficiency. Journals should communicate relevant procedure changes and maintain an accurate public description of how manuscripts are assessed.

Editorial teams may provide reviewer guidance and training to promote constructive and consistent evaluation.

18. Implementation Across Scientific Hub Journals

This policy serves as the centralized peer review framework for Scientific Hub journals. Each journal is expected to:

  • Link visibly to this publisher-wide policy from its website.
  • Identify the peer review model used for its manuscripts.
  • Disclose any discipline-specific requirements or exceptions.
  • Explain relevant editorial decision processes and author responsibilities.
  • Refer serious or unresolved integrity concerns to the appropriate editorial or publisher representative.

If a journal's published policy varies from this framework, the difference must be clear to prospective authors, reviewers and readers.

19. International Guidance and References

This policy is informed by recognized ethical publishing resources, including:

Reference to these organizations does not imply membership, endorsement, accreditation or certification of Scientific Hub.

20. Policy Administration and Contact

Publisher: Scientific Hub

Policy applicability: All Scientific Hub journals, subject to published journal-specific requirements.

Journal-specific inquiries: Contact the editorial office of the relevant journal through its official website.

Publisher-wide ethics concerns: ethics@scientifichubjournals.com

Official website: scientifichubjournals.com

Policy review: This policy is reviewed periodically and updated when necessary. The approved version should remain accessible through the publisher's website.

SCIENTIFIC HUB

Committed to Research Integrity and Responsible Scholarly Publishing

Publisher-wide Peer Review Policy | All Scientific Hub Journals