From Asimov to Alignment: What Science Fiction Can Contribute to Contemporary Debates on Artificial Intelligence – Challenges, Dangers, Ethics and Governance

AI alignment, AI governance, artificial intelligence, magnifica humanitas, science fiction.

Authors

  • Srecko Goic
    goic@efst.hr
    Faculty of Economics, Business and Tourism University of Split Cvite Fiskovića 5 21000, Split, Croatia. , Croatia
November 18, 2026

Downloads

The aim of this paper is to examine what science fiction (SF) can contribute to contemporary ethical, political and regulatory debates on artificial intelligence (AI). Methodologically, it uses interpretive comparative analysis of a corpus ranging from Asimov, Clarke and Herbert to Čapek, Lem and Tezuka, compared with AI-safety literature, recent normative documents (including the encyclical Magnifica humanitas, the International AI Safety Report 2026 and the EU AI Act) and the 2026 OpenAI–Hugging Face incident. The paper builds a typology of six scenarios: rule-bound safe AI, the misaligned optimizer, autonomous military AI, paternalistic AI governance, partnership and coexistence, and prohibition and withdrawal. It finds that SF does not predict technological development but functions as a repertoire of ethical thought experiments that anticipated key governance problems. Self-aware or superhuman AI is treated not as certain or imminent but as one possibility that would pose a significant danger. The paper concludes that the greatest dangers arise when human values are underspecified, authority is delegated without accountability, and societies depend on systems they cannot understand or control.