Plagiarism Policy
SCIENTIFIC HUB
Plagiarism Policy
A Unified Framework for Originality, Similarity Assessment and Research Integrity Across All Scientific Hub Journals
Our Commitment to Originality and Academic Integrity
Scientific Hub is committed to promoting original scholarship, responsible citation practices, transparency and the integrity of the scholarly record. Plagiarism and the misleading presentation of another person's intellectual contributions as one's own are incompatible with responsible academic publishing.
This Plagiarism Policy establishes the principles, responsibilities, screening procedures and editorial responses applicable to manuscripts submitted to journals published, managed or operated under Scientific Hub.
Applicability: All Scientific Hub journals, authors, editors, reviewers and authorized publishing personnel, subject to clearly disclosed journal-specific requirements.
Core Policy Principle
Every submitted manuscript must appropriately acknowledge the intellectual contributions, text, data, images, ideas and other material obtained from existing sources. Similarity reports are screening aids, not independent proof of plagiarism. Editorial decisions are based on evidence, context, attribution and the nature and significance of any identified overlap.
Policy Contents
- Introduction and Scope
- Definition of Plagiarism
- Forms of Plagiarism and Inappropriate Reuse
- Originality Requirements
- Similarity Screening and Assessment
- Interpretation of Similarity Reports
- Citation, Quotation and Paraphrasing
- Self-Plagiarism and Text Recycling
- Duplicate Publication and Prior Dissemination
- Data, Figures, Tables and Images
- Artificial Intelligence and Originality
- Responsibilities of Authors
- Responsibilities of Editors and Reviewers
- Investigation of Suspected Plagiarism
- Editorial Actions Before Publication
- Plagiarism Identified After Publication
- Appeals and Complaints
- Confidentiality and Fair Procedures
- Implementation Across Journals
- International Guidance and References
- Policy Administration and Contact
1. Introduction and Scope
Scientific Hub supports the publication of original, accurate and appropriately attributed scholarly work. The publisher recognizes that the proper acknowledgment of existing knowledge is essential to academic integrity and public confidence in research.
This policy applies to manuscripts submitted to all Scientific Hub journals and to relevant concerns arising before or after publication.
It covers the use and reuse of text, ideas, research findings, data, illustrations, images, tables and other scholarly content. Individual journals may establish additional discipline-specific requirements, provided these are clearly communicated and consistent with applicable ethical standards.
2. Definition of Plagiarism
Plagiarism is the presentation or use of another person's words, ideas, data, research findings, creative expressions or other intellectual contributions without appropriate acknowledgment, in a manner that misrepresents their origin or authorship.
Plagiarism may occur through direct copying, close paraphrasing, inadequate attribution, misrepresentation of sources or unauthorized appropriation of scholarly material.
Plagiarism may occur regardless of whether the material is obtained from a published article, unpublished manuscript, thesis, dissertation, conference paper, book, website, repository or other source.
The seriousness of a concern depends on the nature, extent, significance and circumstances of the material involved. Intent may be relevant to the assessment of misconduct, but the absence of demonstrated intent does not eliminate the need to correct improperly attributed content.
3. Forms of Plagiarism and Inappropriate Reuse
Scientific Hub recognizes several forms of plagiarism and related inappropriate practices, including:
- Direct plagiarism: copying text or other material without appropriate quotation, citation or acknowledgment.
- Mosaic or patchwork plagiarism: combining copied phrases or closely adapted passages from different sources while presenting them as original writing.
- Paraphrasing plagiarism: restating another author's distinctive ideas or arguments without appropriate attribution.
- Idea plagiarism: presenting another person's original concepts, interpretations or research contributions as one's own.
- Data plagiarism: using or presenting another researcher's data or findings without appropriate acknowledgment or authorization.
- Image and figure plagiarism: reproducing or adapting visual material without proper attribution or required permission.
- Translation plagiarism: translating another person's work into a different language and presenting it without appropriate acknowledgment.
- Inappropriate self-reuse: reusing substantial portions of one's previously disseminated work without appropriate disclosure or citation.
- Source misrepresentation: using misleading, fabricated or inaccurate references to conceal the origin of material.
Not every instance of textual overlap constitutes plagiarism. Editors must assess the relevant evidence and context.
4. Originality Requirements
Authors submitting manuscripts to Scientific Hub journals must ensure that their work makes an appropriately original scholarly contribution and accurately distinguishes their contributions from existing literature.
Authors must acknowledge relevant sources, disclose material overlap with their earlier work and comply with the journal's requirements concerning prior publication, preprints, conference proceedings and related manuscripts.
Originality does not require that every sentence or method be entirely new. Established terminology, standard descriptions and properly attributed reuse may be appropriate when justified by scholarly conventions.
5. Similarity Screening and Assessment
Scientific Hub journals may use appropriate similarity-detection software and editorial checks to identify potentially overlapping material in submitted manuscripts.
Screening may take place during initial editorial assessment, peer review, revision or post-publication investigation, depending on the journal's procedures and the circumstances of the case.
Similarity reports may help identify matching text and sources, but they cannot independently determine whether plagiarism has occurred.
Editors must evaluate relevant matches and consider whether the material is properly cited, quoted, disclosed or otherwise justified.
Scientific Hub does not establish a universal numerical similarity threshold in this publisher-wide policy. Any journal-specific screening criteria must be accurately disclosed and applied with appropriate editorial judgment.
6. Interpretation of Similarity Reports
Similarity percentages represent detected textual matches within the coverage and settings of a particular screening system. They are not plagiarism scores and should not be interpreted as direct measures of academic misconduct.
Editors should consider:
- The location, length and significance of matching passages.
- Whether the original sources have been appropriately acknowledged.
- Whether quotations, standard terminology or commonly used methods explain the overlap.
- Whether overlapping content appears in the introduction, methods, results, discussion or conclusions.
- Whether the overlap involves the author's own previously published or disseminated work.
- Whether matching material includes important original findings, interpretations, data or illustrations.
- Whether relevant prior dissemination has been disclosed.
A low similarity percentage does not guarantee originality, and a high percentage does not automatically demonstrate plagiarism. Decisions must be supported by contextual editorial assessment.
7. Citation, Quotation and Paraphrasing
Authors must provide accurate and sufficient citations whenever they rely on the intellectual contributions of other researchers.
Direct quotations should be clearly identified and appropriately referenced in accordance with the relevant journal's disciplinary and formatting requirements.
Paraphrasing must involve genuine reformulation and appropriate acknowledgment. Merely changing a few words or rearranging sentence structures does not make unattributed material original.
Citation alone does not necessarily justify extensive verbatim reproduction. Authors must also comply with applicable copyright, licensing and permission requirements.
8. Self-Plagiarism and Text Recycling
Authors must not present previously published or disseminated material as entirely new when substantial reuse would mislead readers about the originality of the submission.
Text recycling may be acceptable in limited circumstances, particularly for established methodological descriptions, when the reuse is transparent, appropriately attributed and consistent with the journal's policies and applicable rights.
Substantial duplication of results, interpretations or conclusions without appropriate disclosure is unacceptable.
Editors should assess text recycling in context, taking account of disciplinary conventions, transparency, copyright requirements and whether the reuse misrepresents the novelty of the work.
9. Duplicate Publication and Prior Dissemination
Authors must not submit substantially the same manuscript simultaneously to multiple journals unless expressly permitted under applicable editorial arrangements.
Previously published material, related manuscripts, preprints, theses, dissertations, conference abstracts and proceedings must be disclosed where relevant under the receiving journal's policies.
Prior dissemination does not automatically make a manuscript ineligible for consideration. Editors must assess the nature of the earlier dissemination, the degree of overlap and the journal's published requirements.
Redundant publication or the misleading presentation of previously published findings as new research may justify editorial action.
10. Data, Figures, Tables and Images
Authors must appropriately acknowledge the sources of reproduced or adapted data, figures, tables, photographs, illustrations and other visual or research materials.
Permission must be obtained where required by copyright, licensing or other applicable rules. Proper attribution does not replace the need for permission when permission is legally required.
Presenting another researcher's findings or visual material as original work is prohibited. Fabrication, falsification and misleading manipulation of research material are addressed under Scientific Hub's broader publication ethics requirements.
11. Artificial Intelligence and Originality
Authors remain fully responsible for the originality, accuracy, attribution and integrity of all submitted content, including material prepared with artificial intelligence or AI-assisted technologies.
Where AI-assisted tools are permitted, authors must comply with the relevant journal's disclosure requirements and verify the accuracy of generated text, citations, data and other outputs.
AI systems must not be listed as authors. Fabricated references, misleading synthetic research content and unattributed reproduction of protected or previously published material are unacceptable.
AI-generated text detection results should not, by themselves, be treated as conclusive evidence of misconduct. Any concerns must be assessed fairly using appropriate evidence and editorial judgment.
12. Responsibilities of Authors
All authors are expected to:
- Submit original work and acknowledge all relevant sources.
- Use quotations and paraphrases appropriately.
- Disclose overlapping publications and related manuscripts.
- Obtain permissions for third-party material where required.
- Verify references and the accuracy of all submitted content.
- Cooperate with reasonable editorial originality checks.
- Provide explanations or supporting documentation when concerns are raised.
- Correct identified attribution errors promptly and transparently.
All listed authors share responsibility for the integrity of the submitted manuscript in accordance with applicable authorship standards.
13. Responsibilities of Editors and Reviewers
Editors are responsible for assessing credible originality concerns objectively and consistently. They should consider relevant evidence, provide authors with an appropriate opportunity to respond and avoid decisions based solely on automated screening results.
Reviewers who identify possible plagiarism or inappropriate content reuse should confidentially inform the handling editor and provide relevant supporting information where possible.
Reviewers must not independently publicize allegations, misuse unpublished material or upload confidential manuscripts to unauthorized external services.
The Editor-in-Chief or authorized handling editor retains responsibility for editorial decisions.
14. Investigation of Suspected Plagiarism
Credible concerns about plagiarism or inappropriate reuse should be assessed through a fair, evidence-based process.
- Initial assessment: The editor reviews the allegation and relevant manuscript material.
- Source comparison: Potentially overlapping material is compared with the identified sources.
- Contextual evaluation: The editor considers attribution, extent, significance and relevant circumstances.
- Author response: The authors may be asked to provide an explanation, supporting records or corrected material.
- Further consultation: Independent experts, institutional representatives or publisher personnel may be consulted when appropriate.
- Editorial determination: The responsible editor determines the appropriate response based on the available evidence.
- Documentation: Relevant findings and decisions are documented and communicated as appropriate.
Scientific Hub seeks to distinguish minor attribution errors, legitimate overlap and genuine scholarly mistakes from serious or repeated misconduct.
15. Editorial Actions Before Publication
Where plagiarism or inappropriate reuse is identified before publication, possible editorial actions include:
- Requesting clarification or additional documentation.
- Requiring corrected citations, quotations or attribution.
- Requesting substantive manuscript revision.
- Requiring disclosure of related or previously disseminated work.
- Declining the manuscript where serious concerns remain unresolved.
- Rejecting the manuscript where substantial plagiarism or serious misconduct is established.
- Referring serious concerns to an appropriate institution or research-integrity authority where justified.
The response should be proportionate to the nature and seriousness of the concern. A manuscript may be rejected for failing to meet publication standards even where deliberate misconduct has not been established.
16. Plagiarism Identified After Publication
Concerns identified after publication will be evaluated in accordance with the journal's publication ethics procedures and the seriousness of the evidence.
Depending on the circumstances, appropriate measures may include:
- Publishing a correction or clarification.
- Updating attribution or acknowledgment where appropriate.
- Issuing an expression of concern when significant unresolved questions remain.
- Retracting an article where serious plagiarism or other findings justify removal of confidence in the publication.
- Contacting relevant institutions or other affected publishers when necessary and appropriate.
Corrections and retraction notices should be transparent, appropriately linked to the affected article and consistent with recognized publishing ethics guidance.
Retraction is not an automatic consequence of every attribution error. The decision depends on the nature, extent and implications of the problem.
17. Appeals and Complaints
Authors may appeal plagiarism-related editorial decisions when they identify a significant factual error, procedural irregularity, relevant conflict of interest or other substantial grounds for reconsideration.
Appeals should include a clear explanation and supporting evidence and should be submitted to the relevant journal's editorial office.
The appeal should be reviewed by an appropriately authorized editor or independent representative where necessary to preserve impartiality.
An appeal does not guarantee reversal of the original decision.
18. Confidentiality and Fair Procedures
Allegations of plagiarism must be handled impartially, respectfully and with appropriate attention to confidentiality, privacy and procedural fairness.
Relevant information should be shared only with individuals who have a legitimate role in evaluating or resolving the concern, subject to applicable legal and ethical requirements.
Individuals raising concerns in good faith should not be subjected to retaliation. Knowingly false or malicious allegations are also unacceptable.
Editors and publishing personnel must disclose relevant conflicts of interest and withdraw from decisions where their impartiality could reasonably be questioned.
19. Implementation Across Scientific Hub Journals
This policy provides a centralized framework for the prevention, assessment and management of plagiarism across Scientific Hub journals.
Each journal is expected to:
- Provide access to this publisher-wide Plagiarism Policy.
- Communicate originality and attribution requirements to authors.
- Apply fair and appropriate similarity-screening procedures.
- Explain any journal-specific requirements or screening criteria.
- Ensure that similarity results receive appropriate editorial evaluation.
- Address credible allegations before or after publication.
- Refer serious or unresolved concerns to the appropriate publisher representative.
Where a journal adopts additional requirements, these should be clearly disclosed and should not misrepresent the capabilities or meaning of similarity-detection systems.
20. International Guidance and References
This policy is informed by internationally recognized scholarly publishing ethics resources, including:
- Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE)
- International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE)
- World Association of Medical Editors (WAME)
- Council of Science Editors (CSE)
Reference to these organizations does not imply membership, endorsement, accreditation or certification of Scientific Hub.
21. Policy Administration and Contact
Publisher: Scientific Hub
Policy applicability: All Scientific Hub journals, subject to published journal-specific requirements.
Journal-specific inquiries: Contact the editorial office of the relevant journal through its official website.
Publisher-wide ethics concerns: ethics@scientifichubjournals.com
Official website: scientifichubjournals.com
Policy review: This policy is reviewed periodically and updated when necessary to reflect developments in scholarly publishing, research integrity, relevant technology and ethical guidance.
The approved version should remain accessible through the publisher's official website.
SCIENTIFIC HUB
Committed to Original Research, Academic Integrity and Responsible Scholarly Publishing
Publisher-wide Plagiarism Policy | All Scientific Hub Journals




